Evidence ceiling E3Proof boundary

STANDARDS WINDOW · NIST AI 200-2

Real-world outcomes are now an explicit TEVV concern.

NIST's August 7, 2026 initial TEVV-Athlon draft includes agentic systems and seeks comments through October 6, 2026. Finality can contribute a bounded technical comment without claiming endorsement or conformance.

Proposed comment topics

Outcome truth after agent action.

The submission should describe evaluation mechanics rather than market claims.

01

Authorization ≠ outcome

Separate permission and runtime success from authoritative post-state.

02

Authoritative post-state

Name which source is empowered to establish the ending.

03

Contradiction semantics

No material contradiction may coexist with unsupported FINAL.

04

REOPEN

Later governing evidence supersedes prior closure without rewriting history.

05

Institution-owned truth

Hidden cases and expected answers can remain outside seller custody.

06

Operator / evaluator separation

A seller cannot self-award E4 or E5 proof.

07

Six → one composition

Constitutional proofs compose into post-action closure under one transaction identity.

Public knowledge index

Search Finality Group

Protected, owner-only and legacy content is excluded.